Warning: include(/var/www/nbc.com-assets/includes/global/nbc.com_blogs_nav08.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /var/www/blogs.nbcuni.com/nashvillestar/2008/07/contenders_or_pretenders.php on line 92
Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening '/var/www/nbc.com-assets/includes/global/nbc.com_blogs_nav08.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/lib/php/includes:/usr/local/php/includes:/usr/local/php4/lib:/usr/local/lib/php') in /var/www/blogs.nbcuni.com/nashvillestar/2008/07/contenders_or_pretenders.php on line 92
Contenders or Pretenders?
I, like most country music fans, have been chomping at the bit to get to ORIGINALS night, because this is what separates country from other genres of music. The "realness". There's only one John Prine. There's only one Hayes Carl. There's only one Todd Snider. There's only one Robert Earl Keen. You get the picture. And of course, there's only one Willie Nelson.
By the way, did you hear what he had to say about turning 75? He said he's outlived his rooster.
And I'm paraphrasing that a little. But country music has always been about the common man.
Rap music has always been about degrading women and extravagance.
And Polka music
has always been annoying.
So originals night was a complete surprise to me!! Every song was way better than I expected. So let's get to 'em!
First up we had Coffey. I'm as stunned typing it, as he was when they announced it.
Whaaaat? Really? C'mon. I still feel he doesn't belong this far in the competition, and I certainly have trouble believing he's better that Ashlee but this probably falls into the disclaimer of real small text they flash at the end of the show. Nonetheless, the performance was pretty good, but to go on song strength, his was the weakest. I agreed with Jeffrey when he said it was "novelty" because I hate when people just put a bunch of random country adjectives together. Like there's some kind of checklist
of words that you have to have.
"Trucks?"
"Fishing?"
"Grits?.........Where's Grits? This can't be a country song without grits, people."
Also he mentioned a Dodge in the song and this show is sponsored by Toyota, and you could feel the sponsorship liaison grimace at that one.
But it was a catchy enough tune and it was true to who he is, so I guess I have to swallow my grits and move on.
Fade me out..............Fade me out...................Fade me out.........
The rest of the songs were solid enough to be shipped to country radio tomorrow. When I say that I mean after they have been cut by an established artist. Case in point. I worked a single to radio called "Wrapped" by Bruce Robison.
If you've never heard the album, please don't consider yourself a country fan. Anyway we couldn't even get it to chart because Bruce was too new, but it had nothing to do with the song. Fast forward a few years and King George Strait cuts it and releases it to be his 55th #1. And I believe all of those songs after Coffey had the potential to be cut by an established artist in country today, and they would be a hit. Coffey's could be cut by Colt Ford
and not be a hit.
Next we had Melissa Lawson dressed like a Zebra, but making another stellar impression with the crowd. Kinda funny too because her song is called "Ready To Stand" which is the same as the signs someone must hold up at the live tapings, because it is sooooooo annoying to watch an audience be coaxed into standing when they don't want to, but that's the slight of hand that TV uses to make it look more dramatic. The same way there is always hot chicks behind the judges.
Anyway, Melissa continues to showcase why she's the vocal powerhouse
of the show. They say some folks can't carry a tune in a bucket. Take me for example, I like to drink and I like to sing, but I've found that most people would rather listen to me drink than sing. If Melissa can carry a tune in a bucket, I think it would be this one
John Rich keeps telling her to "stay in focus" which I guess means John needs to see the optometrist
The lowlight of the show turned out to be the judges performances. I was so looking forward to this, and I thought they were OK as performances go, but when you spend 6 weeks ripping people apart, you better be as FLAWLESS as you expect, and there were certainly flaws. (Jewel's legs were none of them though). She's guilty of the same "vocal acrobatics" that she chastised Coffey for in the beginning. It was painful to the ears and I love Jewel. Next we had Jeffrey Steele doing a few of his songs and this was ok, but again, I'm expecting to be blown away. But he's more of a writer than performer. Well that's not true, because he was in Boy Howdy, sporting a righteous mullet.
Next was John Rich and....oh....would you look at the time, I better get moving on to the winner.
Gabe Garcia shows no signs of slowing up. His song "Lost Weekend" is a smash. Chesney or Strait would take that song to number one quickly, and it might even be strong enough to break Gabe at radio, but I doubt it.
Poor Ashlee Hewitt, she sings a great original and then gets tossed off the show. And I told you that was a hickey! I want a writing credit on that Mike's Hard Lemonade song. But don't worry about her, there are already rumblings that she has a record deal in the works with a guy named Bugs, and at the very least they should be in contract negotiations with Mike's Hard Lemonade for at least a year (which is when she turns 21).
And Ladies and Gentleman, on the outside making her stride to the finish line like a true dark horse
is Shawn Mayer! Skirting and flirting in the bottom a few times now, she might be playing this thing right, because I think it could come down to her and Gabe possibly. An outstanding song and one that you could hear on the radio today.
So in summation, Contestants - 4 out of 5 stars
Judges - 1 out of 3 stars
As always leave a message at the beep (BEEP)
Was it just me or did Shawn Mayer's song sound A LOT like the song by the Jonas Brothers, "When You Look Me in the Eyes"? Seriously, as soon as she started singing it I new I had heard it before!
And Gabe's was Redneck Yacht Club all over again. But recycling chords and melodies isn't against the rules. His song was still instantly likeable.
Jeffrey Steele did a good job. Remember that we've been conditioned to other people's recordings of his songs. While Jewell was proving to the world that she's not a country singer and John was concentrating on showing off, Jeff came out and made a heart felt performance of his songs. Thanks Jeff.
Looking forward to Ashlee's album...
I agree about the pretty ladies behind the judges. On the Nashville Star website, if you wanted tickets up front...you had to send in a photo. Bummer as I guess a "normal" woman like me would make little children cry and grown men run.
As far as J.Steele being more of a writer than a performer, I challenge you to join the ranks of us Steele fans at 3rd and Lindsley this Friday (7/25). The man blows away any performer I've seen in my lifetime. And he does it nonstop for hours! Amazing talent that guy is.
I DO agree that Shawn is slowly climbing the ranks but is it to much too late? Next week is the deciding factor. She's got that "in-your-face" kinda attitude that's consistent among the newer, younger singers in today's country music field.
It seems Shawn is a bit of a brat with a lot of attitude. Gabe is into the music, but comes off as if he is shy. My favorite is Melissa, love the voice and the emotion, she seems to love performing.
I'm a little confused on Jewels comments to the contestants. It was noticable since the beginning of the show, but straight out unbeliavable tonight. Her comments to the males lasted 12-25 seconds, while to the females they averaged 6. Whats wrong Jewel, scared of a little competion in sales? It wouldn't even be so bad if the comments made since, and maybe if I had 8 or 10 hurricanes they would have, unfortunately I hadn't-but I know better now and will have several before I listen to you try to make sense again. And a side note-when I saw your performance last week-I, like a previous contestant-rolled my eyes
Maybe it is just me, but I still DO NOT, I MEAN DO NOT UNDERSTAND why that WOMAN is "Co- HOSTING" the SHOW. Whose WIFE is she ANYWAY? Could we CRITIQUE her HIDEOUS reading of cue cards? Bless Her HEART.
And The Winner will NOT BE Shawn Mayer. As to WHO anybody's guess. but John Rich asked and stated things to get certain demographics involved in the voting process. One was the question to Melissa that ended with an answer related to doing it for her kids which I think many Mothers identify. Rich hit the nail on the culture card head referring to the Hispanic community and an identifiable force in Country Music. NO DOUBT!
On his Own MERIT, If they had a Country Artist FOCUSED Cover night, and focused on the ICONS WILLIE, MERLE, CASH, or JONES; Garcia would STOMP a MUDHOLE in the competition and WALK it DRY.
This Honestly makes that other show look terrible (IDOL=JOKE).
After tonites show I think Gabe has it by a land slide!! And with Melissa comment about doing it for her kids. Dose she know if she makes it all the way she'll neve see her kids!!
Kelly Willis does the best version of "Wrapped". I like gabe
I don't think country music needs another high pitched screaming female singer right now...and I don't think Shawn is ready to go on the road ~ she's too emotional. SO ~ all I can say is...
"GO GABE GO!!!!"
As far as Shawn goes, I'm not to worried about her making it in Country Music. Shawn has what it takes to be a Country singer, she has commitment, vocal talent, song writing talent, and the heart of a country singer. As far as Melissa if she is as good a mother as she is a singer she will probley make it in country slowly, because I'm sure her family will come first, but I do think she will make her mark in Country Music.
Links
Recent Posts
BlogArchive
Warning: include(/var/www/nbc.com-assets/includes/global/nbc.com_blogs_footer08.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /var/www/blogs.nbcuni.com/nashvillestar/2008/07/contenders_or_pretenders.php on line 371
Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening '/var/www/nbc.com-assets/includes/global/nbc.com_blogs_footer08.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/lib/php/includes:/usr/local/php/includes:/usr/local/php4/lib:/usr/local/lib/php') in /var/www/blogs.nbcuni.com/nashvillestar/2008/07/contenders_or_pretenders.php on line 371
